In chapter 5 Himmelstoss really starts to become the rude, immature man he really is. In the beginning of the chapter he approaches the soldiers who ignore him and tells Tjaden to stand up. Since Tjaden truly hates Himmelstoss why would he stand up for him, instead he moons him and quickly runs away. Himmelstoss is now fed up with the way he has been acting and will soon punish him. Later when Himmelstoss returns to punish Tjaden he is gone and no one says where he has gone. Soon after Himmelstoss takes the men to court but he doesnt really win the battle. Himmelstoss is given a big lecture on how to treat soldiers and that war is a time to be tattletaling for every little thing that goes on.Tjaden is given a 3 day open arrest which really isnt an arrest at all and Kropp gets one day open arrest. You could not even consider it an arrest because their fellow soldiers came over and played cards and ate with them.
After the trial Paul and Kat go to a shed where they had seen geese. They figured that these geese would make a good dinner for them. Paul hops over the fence and finds he is facing 2 geese. They are too much for him and soon start to cackle and squawk when he tries to kill them. Slowly Paul gets the hold of the geese and throws them over to Kat. Together they roast the goose and find themselves getting close. You could describe the mood at the time of the goose roasting as calm and peaceful because the two boys are sitting there making a meal and no one is yelling there is no violence is is just peace. In the book it it says "the hour is like the room: flecked over with the lights and shadows of our feelings cast by a quiet fire". This means the dont know how each other feel. They are both at peace with one another.
Photo: This photo is of the rations that were issued to soldiers during WW1. If i had to eat this food during the war I to would probably kill a goose for food because this is not enough to feed a soldier.
.

Jaaaaaz! Really like your opinion on why Himmelstone is so mean to them. But i feel he is mean to them because he wants to have all this power and glory but no one wants to listen or take orders from him. I also feel the same about the mood in this chapter is calm except Himmelstone he must be feeling depressed and let down.
ReplyDelete" In chapter 5 Himmelstoss really starts to become the rude, immature man he really is." Okay Jazz you really had a good start with saying that Himmelstoss was being immature in this chapter but then your next few sentences didn't have much to do with it." Since Tjaden truly hates Himmelstoss why would he stand up for him, instead he moons him and quickly runs away." Thats not evidence of Himmelstoss is being immature it's an example for Tjaden being immature. Like being immature is nooning someone Tjaden mooned Himmelstoss so your evidence didn't support your thesis here.And I agree with Tim Himmelstoss wasnt immature because he was just being himself it was because he was angry that noone wanted to follow his orders and take him seriously. Over all though pretty good post.;)
ReplyDeleteHey Jazz its me nick here to say this has been a really good post! I mean i really do agree with you when you had said that Himmelstoss had become very immature i think that is totally true. This had been a really nice post.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't really figure out the mood of the goose roast when I read the book. I knew it was something along the lines of peaceful, but I could never really find the right word to describe it. Peaceful fits perfectly. They left the pressures of war, if only just for a moment, to sit down and have a nice quiet meal between friends. That part really said a lot about the deep friendship between Paul and Kat.
ReplyDeleteNice post. Himmelstoss is exposed for his true self in this chapter. Also the whole goose roasting scene was kind of a bonding moment with Paul and Kat. They became close after this tried to stick together as much as they could.
ReplyDelete